📊 Retirement Savings Statistics & Reality Check
64%
of Americans have money invested in a retirement savings plan
36%
don't have any retirement savings at all
44%
of U.S. households own IRAs as of 2024
$38,176
median 401(k) balance in 2024 (all ages combined)
35%
feel they are on track for retirement
11.5%
median contribution rate (employee + employer)
These statistics reveal a stark reality: while the majority of Americans are building retirement wealth through tax-advantaged accounts, more than one-third aren't participating at all. The median 401(k) balance of just $38,176 shows that even among savers, many are significantly behind where they need to be. Understanding the different retirement account types and their unique benefits is the first step toward joining those who are actively preparing for their financial future.
Building wealth for retirement isn't just about how much you save—it's about where you save it. The right retirement account can save you tens of thousands in taxes over your lifetime, while the wrong choice (or no choice at all) can leave you paying Uncle Sam far more than necessary.
Whether you're contributing to your first 401(k), deciding between Roth or traditional options, exploring self-employment accounts, or strategizing for early retirement, understanding your retirement account options is critical. Each account type has unique tax treatments, contribution limits, withdrawal rules, and strategic advantages that can dramatically impact your long-term wealth.
This comprehensive guide breaks down every major retirement account type—from workplace plans like 401(k)s and 403(b)s to individual options like IRAs and HSAs—helping you understand which accounts fit your situation and how to maximize their benefits for your financial future.
💰 Explore Retirement Account Types
🛠️ Interactive Tools & Comparisons
📖 Glossary of Terms
Key terminology to help you understand retirement accounts
Example with $10,000:
• Scenario A - Exclusion (QCD): You have $50K in income. You do $10K QCD. Your taxable income = $40K (the $10K never appears). At 22% bracket: taxes = $8,800.
• Scenario B - Deduction (Cash donation): You have $50K in income. You donate $10K cash. Your income shows as $50K, then deduct $10K (only if itemizing!) = $40K taxable. At 22% bracket: taxes = $8,800 IF you itemize. But if you take standard deduction ($15,000 single), you get NO benefit from the donation - taxes = $11,000 on $50K.
Bottom line: Same $40K taxable income with exclusion, BUT deduction only works if you itemize. Plus, exclusion keeps your AGI at $40K (helps with Medicare premiums, Social Security taxation), while deduction shows $50K AGI initially.
Tax Treatment Comparison
Understanding how different accounts are taxed at contribution, growth, and withdrawal stages
Key Insights:
- Traditional accounts: Pay taxes later (bet on lower tax rate in retirement)
- Roth accounts: Pay taxes now (bet on higher tax rate in retirement or want tax-free income)
- HSA: The only triple tax-advantaged account (best tax treatment available)
- Brokerage: Most flexible but least tax-efficient (use after maxing retirement accounts)
⚖️ Compare Retirement Accounts
Select accounts to compare side-by-side
Select Accounts to Compare:
Select at least one account above to see the comparison table
🎯 The Power of Tax Diversification
Why having multiple types of retirement accounts dramatically reduces your lifetime tax burden and increases flexibility
🏆 The Tax Diversification Advantage
Strategic use of multiple account types can save you $100,000 - $500,000+ in lifetime taxes
Understanding the Three Tax Buckets
- Traditional 401(k)
- Traditional IRA
- SEP IRA
- Solo 401(k) (traditional)
- 403(b)
- 457(b)
- Roth IRA
- Roth 401(k)
- HSA (for medical)
- Brokerage Account
- ESPP
Real-World Scenarios: The Tax Diversification Difference
Profile: Married filing jointly, both age 55. Retire with $2 million saved. Need $80,000/year to live until Social Security starts at 70. 2025 tax rates and $30,000 standard deduction apply.
- Age 55-59 (4.5 years):
- ✗ Can't access without 10% early withdrawal penalty
- ✗ Must withdraw $88,889 gross to net $80,000
- ($88,889 - 10% penalty = $80,000)
- ✗ Tax calculation on $88,889:
- AGI: $88,889 - $30,000 std deduction = $58,889 taxable
- First $23,200 @ 10% = $2,320
- Next $35,689 @ 12% = $4,283
- Total tax: $6,603 + $8,889 penalty = $15,492/year
- Cost over 4.5 years: $69,714 in taxes & penalties
- Age 59.5-70 (10.5 years):
- ✗ No more penalty, but all $80K ordinary income
- $80K - $30K std = $50K taxable
- First $23,200 @ 10% = $2,320
- Next $26,800 @ 12% = $3,216
- Annual tax: $5,536
- Cost over 10.5 years: $58,128 in taxes
- TOTAL 15-YEAR COST: $127,842
- Age 55-59 (4.5 years):
- ✓ Withdraw $80K from brokerage account
- ✓ Assume 50% cost basis, 50% long-term capital gains
- $40,000 in LTCG - $30,000 std deduction = $10,000 taxable gains
- $10,000 @ 0% LTCG rate (below $94,050 threshold)
- Annual tax: $0
- Cost over 4.5 years: $0
- Age 59.5-70 (10.5 years):
- ✓ Withdraw $80K from Roth IRA (100% tax-free!)
- Annual tax: $0
- Cost over 10.5 years: $0
- TOTAL 15-YEAR COST: $0
- 💡 Traditional 401(k) remains untouched, growing tax-deferred for RMDs at 73+
Over 15 years (age 55-70) vs. traditional-only strategy
Key insight: The 0% long-term capital gains bracket is incredibly powerful for early retirees. Plus Roth withdrawals don't count as income, keeping you in low/zero brackets.
Profile: Married filing jointly, age 73. $1.5M in traditional IRA. Required Minimum Distribution (RMD) is $56,600 (3.77% factor). You need $40,000 to live and want to donate $10,000 to charity annually. 2025 standard deduction: $30,000.
- ✗ Must take full $56,600 RMD (all taxable income)
- ✗ Donate $10K cash to charity
- ✗ Taking standard deduction → cash donation provides ZERO tax benefit
- Tax calculation:
- AGI: $56,600
- $56,600 - $30,000 std deduction = $26,600 taxable
- First $23,200 @ 10% = $2,320
- Next $3,400 @ 12% = $408
- Federal tax: $2,728
- ✗ IRMAA Impact: AGI of $56,600 is below $206,000 threshold
- No IRMAA surcharge (this scenario)
- Annual cost: $2,728 in federal tax
- Charity received $10K but you got $0 tax benefit
- You spent $50K total ($40K living + $10K charity)
- ✓ Take $30K from traditional IRA (taxable)
- ✓ QCD $10K directly to charity (excluded from income!)
- ✓ Take $10K from Roth IRA (tax-free)
- ✓ RMD satisfied: $30K + $10K QCD = $40K (meets $56,600 RMD requirement)
- Tax calculation:
- AGI: $30,000 (only the traditional withdrawal)
- QCD is excluded from income entirely
- Roth is tax-free (doesn't appear on return)
- $30,000 - $30,000 std deduction = $0 taxable
- Federal tax: $0
- Annual cost: $0 in federal tax
- Charity received $10K AND you saved $2,728
- You spent $40K total (fully tax-free!)
That's $54,560 saved over 20 years of retirement!
Key insight: The QCD excludes income (better than a deduction), and combining with Roth withdrawals keeps you in the standard deduction sweet spot. Your traditional IRA satisfies RMD while you pay ZERO tax and donate to charity. This is the power of tax diversification!
Profile: Married filing jointly, age 65. Face $50,000 in qualified medical expenses this year (surgery, prescriptions, long-term care premiums). Need to withdraw from retirement to cover costs. 2025 standard deduction: $30,000.
- ✗ Withdraw $50K from traditional 401(k)
- ✗ Entire $50K is ordinary income
- Tax calculation:
- AGI: $50,000
- $50,000 - $30,000 std deduction = $20,000 taxable
- First $20,000 @ 10% = $2,000
- Federal tax: $2,000
- Medical expense deduction?
- Only expenses exceeding 7.5% of AGI are deductible
- 7.5% × $50,000 = $3,750 threshold
- $50,000 - $3,750 = $46,250 deductible IF itemizing
- But standard deduction ($30K) > itemized ($46,250), so...
- Would itemize! $46,250 deduction vs. $30K standard
- Revised: $50,000 - $46,250 = $3,750 taxable
- $3,750 @ 10% = $375 federal tax
- Net cost: $50,375 total
- ($50K medical + $375 tax)
- Withdrew $50K, have $49,625 after tax
- ✓ Withdraw $50K from HSA for qualified medical expenses
- ✓ 100% tax-free (contributions were tax-deductible years ago)
- ✓ Growth was tax-free all those years
- ✓ Withdrawal for qualified medical: completely tax-free
- Tax calculation:
- AGI: $0 (HSA withdrawals for medical don't count!)
- Federal tax: $0
- ✓ Keep other retirement accounts growing tax-deferred
- Net cost: $50,000 total
- ($50K medical + $0 tax)
- Full $50K available for medical expenses
BUT WAIT - there's more value! The real benefit: You got tax deductions on HSA contributions over the years (say $50K contributed over time @ 22% bracket = $11,000 saved then), grew tax-free for decades, AND withdrew tax-free now. Total lifetime benefit: $11,000+ vs. using after-tax dollars or traditional accounts.
Key insight: While the withdrawal tax difference is modest in this scenario (due to medical expense deduction), the HSA's real power was the upfront deduction and decades of tax-free growth. Plus, your traditional 401(k) stays untouched and growing!
Profile: Married filing jointly, age 67. Need $90,000/year total. Social Security provides $40,000/year (combined for both spouses). Need $50,000 more from retirement accounts. 2025 standard deduction: $30,000. (Note: Social Security taxation is complex - we'll show simplified calculations)
- ✗ Withdraw all $50K from traditional 401(k)
- Social Security Taxation (Provisional Income Test):
- Provisional Income = AGI + ½ Social Security + tax-exempt interest
- = $50,000 + ($40,000 × 0.5) + $0
- = $50,000 + $20,000 = $70,000 provisional income
- MFJ threshold: $32K-$44K = 50% taxable, over $44K = 85% taxable
- We're $26K over the $44K threshold
- Result: 85% of SS is taxable = $34,000
- Total Taxable Income:
- $50,000 (traditional) + $34,000 (taxable SS) = $84,000
- $84,000 - $30,000 std deduction = $54,000 taxable
- First $23,200 @ 10% = $2,320
- Next $30,800 @ 12% = $3,696
- Federal tax: $6,016/year
- Annual federal tax: $6,016
- ✓ Take $20K from traditional 401(k)
- ✓ Take $30K from Roth IRA (doesn't count as income!)
- Social Security Taxation (Provisional Income Test):
- Provisional Income = AGI + ½ Social Security + tax-exempt interest
- = $20,000 + ($40,000 × 0.5) + $0
- = $20,000 + $20,000 = $40,000 provisional income
- MFJ: Between $32K-$44K = 50% of SS taxable
- We're $8K over $32K threshold but under $44K
- Result: 50% of SS taxable = $20,000
- Total Taxable Income:
- $20,000 (traditional) + $20,000 (taxable SS) + $0 (Roth excluded!) = $40,000
- $40,000 - $30,000 std deduction = $10,000 taxable
- First $10,000 @ 10% = $1,000
- Federal tax: $1,000/year
- Annual federal tax: $1,000
- 💡 The Roth withdrawal doesn't increase AGI, keeping provisional income low!
Over 25 years of retirement: $125,400 in tax savings!
Key insight: By mixing traditional and Roth withdrawals, you control your provisional income, which determines Social Security taxation. More Roth = less SS taxed = lower overall tax. You stay in the 10% bracket instead of 12%, AND reduce SS taxation from 85% to 50%. This is the power of tax diversification!
Profile: Married filing jointly, age 68. Need $50,000/year in retirement (no other income). Saved $1.5M over career. 2025 standard deduction: $30,000.
- During Working Years (ages 25-65):
- ✗ Contributed $1.5M to Roth accounts over 40 years
- ✗ Paid taxes on every dollar (let's say average 22% bracket)
- Total taxes paid: ~$330,000 over career
- Retirement (each year):
- ✗ Withdraw $50K from Roth IRA (tax-free)
- Tax calculation:
- AGI: $0 (Roth withdrawals don't count)
- Taxable income: $0
- Federal tax: $0/year
- ⚠️ THE PROBLEM:
- You have a $30,000 standard deduction going UNUSED every year. If you had $30K in traditional accounts, those withdrawals would be covered by the standard deduction and effectively NEVER TAXED. But you already paid 22% tax on that money years ago!
- Lifetime "wasted" taxes: $6,600/year × 25 years = $165,000
- (You paid 22% tax on $30K/year that could have been withdrawn at 0% tax)
- During Working Years (ages 25-65):
- ✓ Contributed $750K to traditional (got tax deduction)
- Tax savings: ~$165,000 (22% × $750K)
- ✓ Contributed $750K to Roth (paid taxes)
- Taxes paid: ~$165,000 (22% × $750K)
- Net taxes during career: $0 difference vs. all-Roth
- Retirement (each year):
- ✓ Withdraw $30K from traditional IRA
- ✓ Withdraw $20K from Roth IRA
- Tax calculation:
- AGI: $30,000 (only traditional counts)
- $30,000 - $30,000 std deduction = $0 taxable income
- Federal tax: $0/year
- ✅ THE ADVANTAGE:
- You fully utilize the $30,000 standard deduction! The $30K from traditional accounts is covered by the deduction, meaning it was NEVER TAXED (no tax during contributions due to deduction, no tax during withdrawal due to standard deduction). The $20K Roth provides tax-free income above that.
- Lifetime tax savings: $165,000
- (You got 22% deduction on $30K/year, then paid 0% tax on withdrawal = 22% net savings)
The Math: Over 25 years of retirement, you save $6,600/year by having traditional dollars to "fill up" your standard deduction space.
🎯 Key Principle - "Fill the Buckets in Order":
- First $30,000: Traditional → Covered by standard deduction = 0% total tax
- Next $23,200: Traditional → 10% bracket = low tax
- Next $70,600: Traditional → 12% bracket = still reasonable
- Above $123,800: Now Roth makes more sense (22%+ brackets)
💡 Bottom Line: Having ONLY Roth means you paid taxes unnecessarily on dollars that could have been withdrawn tax-free using the standard deduction. You want a mix of traditional (to fill low brackets) and Roth (for higher spending needs).
🎓 Key Takeaways: Your Tax Diversification Action Plan
1. Build All Three Tax Buckets Early: Don't put all eggs in one basket. Traditional, Roth, and taxable accounts each serve different purposes.
2. Prioritize HSA if Available: It's the only triple tax-advantaged account. Max it out before even considering a Roth IRA.
3. Use Brokerage for Early Retirement Bridge: If you plan to retire before 59½, you need accessible funds. Long-term capital gains rates (0-20%) beat early withdrawal penalties (10% + income tax).
4. Strategic Roth Conversions: In low-income years (job loss, sabbatical, early retirement), convert traditional to Roth to "fill up" lower tax brackets.
5. Master the QCD Strategy: At 70½+, QCDs are far superior to cash donations for those taking the standard deduction. They exclude income entirely (better than a deduction).
6. Control Your Tax Bracket in Retirement: Mix traditional (taxable) and Roth (tax-free) withdrawals strategically to stay in the 12% or 22% bracket instead of 24-32%.
7. Reduce Social Security Taxation: Roth withdrawals don't count toward "provisional income" that determines how much of your Social Security is taxed (0%, 50%, or 85%).
8. Avoid IRMAA Surcharges: Use Roth/HSA/QCD to keep Modified AGI below Medicare premium surcharge thresholds ($106K single / $212K married). Saves $1,000-$6,000/year on Medicare.
⚠️ Common Mistakes to Avoid
- ❌ Only contributing to traditional 401(k): You'll have a "tax bomb" in retirement with huge RMDs and no tax-free income to optimize brackets
- ❌ Only contributing to Roth: You miss out on current-year tax savings when you're in a high bracket. Even worse: In retirement, you could have withdrawn up to the standard deduction amount ($30,000 for married couples in 2025) from traditional accounts at 0% tax, but instead you already paid taxes on those dollars! Example: If you only have Roth and withdraw $50K/year, you paid taxes on all $50K. But if you had traditional + Roth, you could take $30K traditional (covered by standard deduction = $0 tax) + $20K Roth (tax-free) = same $50K but with $30K that was NEVER taxed. This is "wasted" standard deduction space.
- ❌ Ignoring HSA: It's objectively the best retirement account tax-wise if you're eligible
- ❌ Not having taxable accounts for early retirement: You're trapped until 59½ or paying penalties
- ❌ Taking full RMD and then donating cash: Use QCD instead to exclude income from taxable income
- ❌ Not coordinating withdrawals: Taking all from traditional pushes you into higher brackets unnecessarily
🎯 Key Takeaways
- The 2025 401(k) contribution limit is $23,500, with an additional $7,500 catch-up for ages 50+ (or $11,250 for ages 60-63)
- IRA contribution limits remain at $7,000 ($8,000 for ages 50+), but Roth IRAs have income phase-outs starting at $150K (single) and $236K (married)
- Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) now start at age 73 for those born 1951-1959, and age 75 for those born in 1960 or later
- Roth 401(k) accounts are no longer subject to RMDs as of 2024, making them more attractive for estate planning
- Self-employed individuals can contribute significantly more through SEP IRAs (up to $70,000) or Solo 401(k)s (up to $70,000, or $77,500 if 50+)
- Always capture the full employer match in your 401(k)—it's free money with an immediate 50-100% return
- HSAs offer a unique triple tax advantage when used for healthcare: tax-deductible contributions, tax-free growth, and tax-free withdrawals for qualified medical expenses
- The 457(b) plan is the only retirement account that allows penalty-free withdrawals at any age after separating from service
- Rule of 55: If you leave your job in the year you turn 55 or later, you can withdraw from that employer's 401(k) or 403(b) penalty-free—this does NOT apply to IRAs
- Taxable brokerage accounts have no contribution limits, no withdrawal penalties, and more flexibility than retirement accounts—essential for early retirement or major pre-retirement goals
- Diversifying across account types (traditional, Roth, and taxable) provides tax flexibility in retirement and hedges against future tax rate changes
- Consider contributing to Roth accounts when you're in a lower tax bracket (early career, low-income years) and traditional accounts when in higher brackets
- Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCDs) from IRAs allow those 70½+ to donate up to $108,000 annually (2025) directly to charity, satisfying RMD requirements while excluding the distribution from taxable income